September 1, 2018
Many of the start-ups at Society for Innovation and Development, based at IISc, have a longer investment horizon than today’s venture capitalists want to bother with
Towards the end of his career, Albert Einstein said: “One thing I have learned in a long life: That all our science, measured against reality, is primitive and childlike—and yet, it is the most precious thing we have.”
He was right. Yet, when we think of the pure sciences, we think of men and women dressed in white laboratory coats, pottering about absentmindedly while thinking thoughts too deep for most of us to fathom. We seldom think of them as doing anything that is going to be of any immediate practical or transactional value in our daily lives.
This is also so with start-ups. Our fascination is for those start-ups that are based on the premise of quick money by “disrupting” existing business models in a way where they immediately become valued as businesses worth untold millions of dollars. Our other fascination is with the technologies themselves—artificial intelligence, machine learning, predictive analytics and so on, and not with pure science. To quote from an article authored by N.J. Brooks et al, and published by the Royal Society, the goal of technology is to get something done, irrespective of whether we understand how it works, while the goal of science is to understand. The “eureka” moment for a technologist is “it works!”; for the scientist, it is “I see!”
Luckily, some of the alumni of the Indian Institute of Science (IISc) in Bengaluru, the hallowed institute first endowed by Jamsetji Tata, think differently than most in the start-up world. Last week, I met C.S. Murali, whom I have known for a long time, and C.V. Natraj, who shared the Royal Society’s article with me. Murali is the chairman and Natraj the chief technical adviser of the Society for Innovation and Development (SID) at IISc. SID is based in IISc’s verdant campus reminiscent of a Bengaluru before the technologists ruined it in their wake. SID was set up with the express purpose of incubating world class start-ups based on deep science that are both commercially viable while also having the ability to “give back” with wide societal impact. While SID was originally meant only for those with direct connections to IISc, it has now broadened its remit to include all comers who fulfil both the above criteria.
One such start-up at SID is led by a famed aeronautical scientist. It is developing a drone that can carry payloads of up to 10kg over long distances. Before you dismiss this as a toy, or liken it to Amazon’s experiments with drones for delivery of its parcels, stop to remember that just recently, the news media was agog with how the police had created a special corridor to the airport so that a donor’s heart could be flown from Chennai to Bengaluru airport and thence to a Bengaluru hospital for a heart transplant. No existing drone was then capable of carrying a payload of that weight over the distance. This start-up, if successful, could revolutionize certain types of critical medical care.
At the other end of the medical care spectrum at SID is a start-up that is focused on creating a high-precision box that uses a “lab on a chip” and can perform sophisticated laboratory tests, without laboratory technicians, on 14 essential parameters on blood samples—for which, today, one needs to travel to a clinical laboratory. Rural India has as much of a deficit of such laboratories as our urban areas have a surfeit. Placing one of these small boxes in villages within a taluk can immediately enhance the quality of basic medical care in the taluk since local physicians will have immediate access to a full panel of blood tests for their patients. SID has several other start-ups that focus on other areas. One is attempting to build and launch low-orbit satellites to support millimetre wave spectrum, which is today available aplenty, is much cheaper than 3G or 4G spectrum, and relies on line of sight. It works much like satellite TV, but is fine tuned to the point where its latency (or speed) is at 10 milliseconds, and not at today’s latency average of 400 milliseconds. As our need for spectrum grows, this could be a viable breakthrough solution for our telecom providers.
Many of the start-ups at SID have a longer investment horizon than today’s venture capitalists want to bother with. These latter want to force an exit to monetize their stake within two to three years. While the Indian government has so far been happy to provide IISc, now a governmental institution, with infrastructure, it is only slowly getting around to considering investment in start-ups. SID has been reliant on a few angel investors or on corporate social responsibility doles to help fund its start-ups. When he meets with philanthropists, Murali channels Jamsetji Tata who said: “There is one kind of charity common enough among us…it is that patchwork philanthropy which clothes the ragged, feeds the poor, and heals the sick. I am far from decrying the noble spirit which seeks to help a poor or suffering fellow being. However, what advances a nation or a community is not so much to prop up its weakest and most helpless members, but to lift up the best and the most gifted, so as to make them of the greater service to the country.”
SID’s dependence on philanthropy is unfortunate. We need to consider investing in these enterprises simply because the passion of these researchers is bound to eventually arrive at results of immense value. Einstein comes to the rescue again when I seek to close by finding words to describe this passion. He said: “The state of mind which enables a man to do work of this kind is akin to the religious worshipper or the lover—the daily effort comes from no deliberate intention or programme, but straight from the heart”.
Sometimes, just sometimes, maybe inner passion should guide our investing philosophy more than immediate profit.
Siddharth Pai is a world-renowned technology consultant who has led over $20 billion in complex, first-of-a-kind outsourcing transactions.
Source: https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/NpwlzCShmBIXqp0IlhL73I/Startups-and-science.html